Practice · 01

Contracts

Every business runs on a handful of documents. Getting those right is where most legal trouble can be headed off.

DOCET LEGAL drafts, reviews and negotiates the commercial contracts NSW businesses trade on, from supply and service agreements to terms of trade and NDAs. Most reviews and drafts are a fixed fee, agreed in writing before work starts. This is the centre of the practice.

The work

A contract is a set of decisions about what happens when things go wrong. Who pays when a delivery is late. Whether you can walk away, and on how much notice. Whose fault a data breach is. Most businesses sign these decisions without reading them, because the document arrived at the end of a negotiation that felt finished.

The practice reads them. Contracts from the other side get a mark-up and a plain note on what to push back on. Contracts you issue get written for the way your business actually trades, so the terms say what happens when a customer disputes an invoice or a supplier fails to deliver. And where the deal is still being shaped, the practice works on the heads of agreement, which is where the leverage is usually set.

Fixed fees for most of it. A review is quoted before it starts, a first draft is quoted before it starts, and if the document changes shape the fee is agreed with you again before the extra work starts, not increased after the event.

This work includes

Watch

Short films, each under a minute. One decided case, or a provision or a few related sections of an Act, told in plain words.

THE LAW SAYS

Unfair terms in small business contracts

A supplier hands you its standard contract: take it or leave it.

Australian Consumer Law (Cth) ss 23-25, 27, 305 53 seconds Law as at 18 October 2026

Read the transcript

You run a small business. A supplier hands you its standard contract, take it or leave it, with one-sided terms buried inside.

Under the Australian Consumer Law, an unfair term in a standard form small business contract is void. The rest of the contract can stand.

A term is unfair only if it causes a significant imbalance, isn't reasonably needed to protect the party it favours, and would cause detriment.

For contracts made, renewed or varied since the ninth of November 2023, it's enough that either side has under one hundred employees or ten million dollars turnover.

And since then, proposing or relying on an unfair term can attract heavy court penalties.

Signing a template? Ask about one-sided terms before you sign. Drafting one? Review it first.

Have us review your template. docetlegal.com.au

General information, not legal advice.

CASE IN POINT

Paciocco v ANZ: the $35 late fee

Is a $35 late fee a penalty?

Paciocco v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd [2016] HCA 28 48 seconds Law as at 18 October 2026

Read the transcript

A thirty-five dollar late fee. The trial judge found the bank's loss on each late payment was probably no more than three dollars.

A customer's ANZ credit cards carried a late fee for missing the minimum payment: thirty-five dollars, later twenty.

He led a class action, calling the fee a penalty. The bank said late payment cost it more.

The trial judge said penalty. The Full Federal Court said no, and the case went to the High Court.

The High Court agreed, four judges to one: not a penalty. It wasn't out of all proportion to the bank's interest in being paid on time.

The lesson. A fee isn't a penalty just because it beats the direct cost. But one out of all proportion still fails.

Have your fees checked. docetlegal.com.au

Dramatised from the published reasons of the High Court of Australia. General information, not legal advice.

CASE IN POINT

Victoria Park Racing v Taylor: the platform overlooking the racecourse

Some racegoers stayed home to hear the race call instead.

Victoria Park Racing and Recreation Grounds Company Limited v Taylor (1937) 58 CLR 479 50 seconds Law as at 22 October 2026

Read the transcript

Sydney, the nineteen thirties. A platform on a neighbour's land overlooked a racecourse. A radio caller described every race live, and some racegoers stayed home to listen.

The course charged for entry. The broadcasters paid the neighbour a pound each time the platform was used.

The course sued the neighbour, the station and its caller, and lost at trial.

The course argued nuisance, property in the spectacle, and copyright. It appealed straight to the High Court.

Three judges to two, the course lost again. Looking over a fence and describing what you see isn't, by itself, a legal wrong to the business inside.

The law won't fence your event for you. Control who can see it, and set terms for the people you let in.

Have us draft your event terms. docetlegal.com.au

Dramatised from the published reasons of the High Court of Australia. General information, not legal advice.

CASE IN POINT

Shao v Crown Global Capital: paid into the wrong account

Two lenders. Paid to one. Gone overseas.

Shao v Crown Global Capital Pty Ltd (in prov liq) [2025] HCA 43 49 seconds Law as at 22 October 2026

Read the transcript

A million-dollar loan from two lenders. Repaid into one lender's own account, and almost all of it sent overseas.

Two lenders put a million dollars into a company's loan note. Repayment had to go to their account, as they notified.

Near the end, the borrower asked one lender where to pay. He gave his own account. She sued him first, and recovered little.

The lower courts said suing him meant she'd accepted the debt was paid, so she couldn't sue the borrower.

All five judges disagreed. The clause also promised not to pay into any account both lenders hadn't nominated, and she could sue for that.

If your contract says where money must be paid, pay only there. Paying elsewhere can leave you paying again.

Have us check the payment terms. docetlegal.com.au

Dramatised from the published reasons of the High Court of Australia. General information, not legal advice.

CASE IN POINT

Electricity Generation Corporation v Woodside Energy Ltd: reasonable endeavours

Gas ran short for a time. Extra gas came at market price.

Electricity Generation Corporation v Woodside Energy Ltd [2014] HCA 7 46 seconds Law as at 23 October 2026

Read the transcript

An explosion at another company's gas plant cut Western Australia's supply for a time. Extra gas came at market price.

A power generator bought gas from Woodside and other sellers. A set daily amount was firm. Extra gas, only reasonable endeavours.

The sellers had the gas, but wouldn't sell it at the contract price. The buyer paid market price, under protest.

The buyer lost at trial, then won in Western Australia's Court of Appeal. Could the sellers weigh their business interests?

Four of five High Court judges found no breach. This clause let the sellers weigh their business interests.

A reasonable endeavours promise is not absolute. Before relying on one, read what the clause lets the other side weigh.

Have us draft your supply terms. docetlegal.com.au

Dramatised from the published reasons of the High Court of Australia. General information, not legal advice.

CASE IN POINT

Associated Newspapers v Bancks: the front page promise

Promised the comic section's front page. Got its third page, three Sundays running.

Associated Newspapers Ltd v Bancks [1951] HCA 24 43 seconds Law as at 23 October 2026

Read the transcript

A paper promised an artist its comic section's front page. Three Sundays running, his drawing ran on that section's third page.

He signed for ten years on a weekly salary. Each week's drawing would lead the comic section.

A newsprint shortage changed the printing. He objected, nothing changed, and he wrote that he was no longer bound.

The paper sued to enforce the contract's restraints against him. It lost in the New South Wales Supreme Court, and appealed.

The High Court agreed unanimously: the front page promise was essential, and three breaches let him end the contract.

A minor broken term usually means damages only. If a promise is why you're signing, say it's essential.

Have us draft your key terms. docetlegal.com.au

Dramatised from the published reasons of the High Court of Australia. General information, not legal advice.

CASE IN POINT

Toll (FGCT) Pty Limited v Alphapharm Pty Limited: signed, unread, bound

Should signing bind you if you never read it?

Toll (FGCT) Pty Limited v Alphapharm Pty Limited [2004] HCA 52 51 seconds Law as at 31 October 2026

Read the transcript

Above a manager's signature, the form said to read the conditions overleaf first. He didn't. Nothing stopped him.

His company was booking a carrier for flu vaccine. The back page said the carrier wasn't responsible for damage, whatever the cause.

Wrong temperatures damaged the vaccine. Its owner sued. The owner itself had signed nothing before the losses.

The owner won more than six hundred and eighty thousand dollars at trial, and again on appeal. Could one unread page undo that?

All five High Court judges said yes. The owner had authorised the signer's company to agree the carrier's standard terms, so it was bound too.

Signed contract terms generally bind you, read or not. But some laws can override unfair terms in standard form contracts with small businesses.

We can review your contracts. docetlegal.com.au

Dramatised from the published reasons of the High Court of Australia. General information, not legal advice.

CASE IN POINT

Koompahtoo Local Aboriginal Land Council v Sanpine Pty Limited: no proper books, breaches to the root

Would you end the deal, or stay in and sue?

Koompahtoo Local Aboriginal Land Council v Sanpine Pty Limited [2007] HCA 61 51 seconds Law as at 31 October 2026

Read the transcript

Over the years, a joint venture's manager kept no ledger, no journal and no cashbook for it.

In 1997 a Local Aboriginal Land Council and Sanpine went fifty fifty. The council brought land; Sanpine ran it, promising proper books.

No budgets or monthly reports were prepared. In 2003, unable to get the figures, the council ended it. Were those breaches enough?

Sanpine sued. It lost at trial, then won two to one on appeal. Nobody had complained earlier. Did that matter?

All five High Court judges upheld the ending. Without books the council couldn't see what was happening, so its earlier silence didn't stop it ending the deal.

The Court didn't decide if the books term was essential. A breach going to the root can still end a contract.

We can review your contracts. docetlegal.com.au

Dramatised from the published reasons of the High Court of Australia. General information, not legal advice.

CASE IN POINT

Ringrow Pty Ltd v BP Australia Pty Ltd: a buy-back option and a fuel supply deal

Would you sign an exclusive supply deal with a buy-back?

Ringrow Pty Ltd v BP Australia Pty Ltd [2005] HCA 71 54 seconds Law as at 31 October 2026

Read the transcript

A service station owner sold another supplier's fuel, against its BP deal. Then BP gave notice it would buy the site back.

In nineteen ninety-nine it bought the site from BP, with a supply deal and a BP option to buy it back.

In two thousand and two, BP gave notice ending the supply deal. The owner called the buy-back a penalty. Was it?

The price was market value, set by an independent valuer, with goodwill left out. Did that make the buy-back a penalty?

All six judges agreed. No dollar value was proved for the goodwill, so no penalty was shown. BP was entitled to buy the site back.

The Court refused a general proportionality test. A penalty must be out of all proportion. Today, unfair contract terms law could reach a term like this in a standard form small business contract.

We can review your supply terms. docetlegal.com.au

Dramatised from the published reasons of the High Court of Australia. General information, not legal advice.

How it usually runs

  1. Send the document, or the deal

    A draft from the other side, your own template that has drifted, or a page of notes on what has been agreed in principle. Any of the three is a starting point.

  2. A fixed fee, in writing, before work starts

    Most contract reviews and most first drafts are quoted as a fixed amount once the document and the purpose are known. If it needs a second round with the other side, that is quoted too.

  3. A marked-up document and a short note

    Tracked changes on the contract itself, and a covering note that says which points matter, which are worth conceding, and what to say to the other side. Not a memo you have to decode.

  4. Negotiation, if you want it

    Some clients take the mark-up and run the conversation themselves. Others want the practice on the call or on the email chain. Both work, and the fee is quoted for whichever you choose.

Where the line is

  • Leases are contracts too, but they run through The Leasing Lawyer, the practice's dedicated leasing site.
  • If a contract dispute has to be decided by a court, the file goes to a litigator, with the groundwork done. Negotiation, mediation, tribunal work, and arbitration and expert determination in NSW stay here.

Nobody pays anybody for a referral here, in either direction. How the practice hands work on →

Common questions

  • How long does a contract review take?

    It depends on the document and what is riding on it. The timing is set out in writing with the fee, before anything is agreed, so if a deal is waiting on the review, say so when you send it. A long or unusual agreement, or one with several schedules, takes longer.

  • Is it cheaper to use a template from the internet?

    Cheaper on the day. The templates that circulate are often written for another country, another industry, or a party on the other side of your deal. The expensive part is discovering that twelve months in, when a clause you never read decides who pays. A short review of the template you already use is often the better spend.

  • Can you draft standard terms my business can reuse?

    Yes. One set of terms of trade or service terms, written for how your business actually operates, and then reused on every quote and invoice. The unfair contract terms rules in the Australian Consumer Law now apply to many small business contracts, so standard terms are also checked against those.

  • The other side says their contract is non-negotiable. Is it?

    Sometimes. Franchise agreements and bank documents rarely move much. Supplier terms, service contracts and most commercial agreements move more than people expect. The point of a review is to tell you which is which before you spend goodwill on a clause that will not shift.

Make an enquiry

Send a short note about what is happening. You will hear back within one business day with whether the practice can help and the fee basis. The fee is confirmed in writing before any work starts.

Send an enquiry All practice areas →